Super Bowl XXIII vs San Francisco 49ers
A miraculous comeback fell short on a single play that changed history.
Super Bowl XXIII, played on January 29, 1989, at Joe Robbie Stadium in Miami, stands as a defining moment of heartbreak and near-glory for the Cincinnati Bengals. Facing the heavily favored San Francisco 49ers, led by Hall of Famer Joe Montana, the Bengals mounted one of the most remarkable comebacks in Super Bowl history. The game is remembered not just for its dramatic finish, but for showcasing the resilience of a young team that had finally reached football's pinnacle.
- Date
- January 29, 1989
- Location
- Joe Robbie Stadium, Miami
- Result
- San Francisco 49ers defeated Cincinnati Bengals 20-16
- MVP
- Jerry Rice (WR, SF)
- Key Turnover
- Montana intercepted by Lewis in the end zone
- Final Drive
- Bengals drove to the 5-yard line with seconds remaining
Lore & Background
The emotional core of this match lies in its final seconds. With only moments left on the clock, the Bengals drove down the field to the San Francisco five-yard line, needing a touchdown to win. The atmosphere was electric with hope as the offense lined up for what would be their last stand. Instead of a victory that would have cemented their legacy immediately, the play resulted in an incomplete pass, handing the 49ers their fourth Super Bowl title and leaving Bengals fans with a memory of 'what could have been' rather than a championship trophy.
In Their Own Story
The humid Miami air hung heavy over Joe Robbie Stadium as the clock ticked down to zero. On the sideline, Boomer Esiason wiped sweat from his brow, his eyes fixed on the field where the offense had just stalled at the five-yard line. The roar of the crowd shifted instantly from a deafening cheer to a collective gasp of disbelief. In that frozen moment, the dream of bringing a championship home to Cincinnati evaporated into the night sky, leaving only the echo of a near-miss that would haunt and inspire fans for decades.
Reader's Guide
The game began with San Francisco establishing dominance, taking an early lead through methodical drives. The turning point arrived in the third quarter when safety Keith Butler intercepted Joe Montana, setting up a crucial Bengals score to spark their comeback. Cincinnati's offense exploded after halftime, led by Ickey Woods' powerful running and Boomer Esiason's clutch passing. They erased a 12-point deficit to take a brief lead before the 49ers responded with a field goal late in the game. The final minutes are etched in history: the Bengals drove down the field against time, reaching the San Francisco five-yard line with seconds left. The game ended on an incomplete pass by Esiason, sealing a heartbreaking 20-16 loss.
Did You Know?
- This was the first Super Bowl to feature two teams that had both lost their previous appearance in the championship game (Bengals from SB XVI and 49ers from SB XIX).
- The Bengals' final drive covered 68 yards in just 30 seconds before the incomplete pass ended the game.
More in Iconic Matches & Games
Elsewhere in the Cincinnati Bengals universe
Spotted an error? Know more?
This is a living reference — every entry is fact-audited, and reader corrections feed straight into our audit queue. Suggest an edit · See this site's audit record